TAMSIBLING'S BLOG

TamSibling

Whoa, whoa, wait a minute, let me explain!
Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Okay, so no doubt some of you have probably read my latest one-shot, Disoriented, which has hints of slashiness between Simon and Mal.

And no doubt, some of you are sitting in front of your screens, scratching your heads and wondering where exactly your faithful Kaylee/Simon-Mal/Inara-shipping TamSibling has gone.

Never fear, I am still around! However, I felt that maybe I needed to explain myself - just a wee bit.

I've been reading a lot of fanfic, and have become quite enamored with the idea of Mal/Simon. And no, it is not because of the guy-on-guy action - in truth, that does nothing for me.

Rather, it's because of this:

Simon, as a character, can be vulnerable, and personally I think he's at his cutest when he is. However, when Simon is in a relationship with Kaylee he is, quite literally, the man. This prevents him from showing weakness of any kind, even when his crazy, schizophrenic sister is running around killing rooms full of Reavers.

With Mal, on the other hand, Simon has the "permission," if you will, to show his emotions and vulnerability and know that Mal will understand. The Captain after all survived Serenity Valley which was a horror in and of itself. Plus, Simon knows that Mal will not think any less of him and will be strong enough to handle it. I just don't think this is the case with Kaylee. Which is not to imply Kaylee is weak - however, if Simon were to really lose it, I don't know how Kaylee would deal. I have a feeling she'd be so worried for him that it would almost make it worse for Simon.

Needless to say, this dichotomy fascinates me. Also, just for your own edification, Disoriented originally had a Simon/Kaylee ending, however, after reading it Kaynara said I should turn it into Mal/Simon and I had to admit, begrudgingly, that while I was writing it, the thought did spring to mind.

I do not anticipate writing any other Mal/Simon - EVER. Do I think that the characters of Mal and Simon are gay? No. Is this AU? Yes.

If you are a regular reader of my stuff, I hope Disoriented hasn't turned you off completely. If the idea bothers you, I'm begging you not to read it. I have hundreds of pages of banked stories on my hard drive full of S/K and M/I goodness, so there is more to come.

If you did like this little fic departure of mine, then great. I certainly hope you left me a comment to let me know!

Thanks for listening to me ramble. Now back to your regularly scheduled programming ...

~TamSibling~

COMMENTS

Thursday, May 24, 2007 3:24 AM

MAL4PREZ


I guess I shouldn't rant about Kaylee when I haven't been keeping up with your Kaylee fics - but I was going with what you said about her in this post. Your plans for for her in the future of your fic sound interesting!

Anyway, thanks for taking my opinionated ramblings so kindly! :)

Wednesday, May 23, 2007 11:18 AM

BLUEEYEDBRIGADIER


Well...I have already dropped a big ole comment over at "Disoriented" but I will throw in my $0.02 cents here as well;)

I personally don't think that "Disoriented" has to be classified as an alternative universe story or that Mal and Simon are struggling with having same-aex attraction feelings for one another. Mal and Simon are in fun places respectively and I could totally see them gravitating toward each other, since Inara is buggering off to the Training House and Kaylee is still in emotional fluff mode.

Speaking of Simon/Kaylee long-term pairings...I generally have to agree with mal4prez. There has to be some serious evolution on the part of both characters if their relationship is to last longer than a few months or years. Kaylee is a strong woman...but admittedly a tad too emotionally-driven pre-BDM. I would like to think that Joss & co. would have really done a number of Kaylee's character had the series gone on longer. Something Willow-like in scope and arc, but without the world-ending in the penultimate season finale;)

BEB

Wednesday, May 23, 2007 6:18 AM

TAMSIBLING


Mal4Prez - I agree with you on the whole Kaylee issue. It is up to us writers to portray as being able to handle the emotional backlash of Simon being so distraught in this unwelcome and disorienting situation he's landed in.

I'm actually working on that now, in the third part to my Best Intentions trilogy - Unforeseen Consequences. Kaylee has gone toe to toe with quite a few people to not only defend Simon, but also stood up to Simon and reminded him he's not invincible and that's okay. It is different for me than how I normally betray them, but I really like it.

Thanks for the feedback. As always, it means a lot.

Wednesday, May 23, 2007 4:08 AM

MAL4PREZ


Hey - explore all you want! I actually see the charm in Mal/Simon as well, though it's *solidly* in the AU realm.

May I just argue something (Sorry, I'm argumentative lately - you're not my first victim this week LOL!)

Honestly, one of the reasons I can't get into all these S/K marriage love fest fics is the thing you explain here - I don't see it as mutually fulfilling. Given the way Kaylee is generally written in fanfic (emotional cream puff), Simon has no other choice but hide his own needs from her - but is that a good basis for any lasting relationship? One person faking it? I think that's the draw to Mal/Simon, the need for equality in a romance...

IMHO, Kaylee needs to step up and carry her fair share of the emotional load, or the S/K relationship will fail. A writer who portrays her as unable to do so, and yet has S/K be all lifelong loving, is writing a disney fairy tale and not the kind of human relationship that fits into Joss's complex `verse.

What I'd love to see is you branching out into a `verse where Kaylee CAN handle Simon's vulnerability. This assumption that Simon has to be The Man.... you know, I think that whole concept has no place in Joss's verse. (Which is why I love it so!) And I'm not convinced that the S/K relationship can't be just as satisfying and equal as what you imagine between Mal and Simon.

I guess it all depends on how we interpret Kaylee, but I won't go off on that tangent...

Tuesday, May 22, 2007 11:14 PM

CHAZZER


Oh don't worry, I won't desert ya! I enjoyed your moment of madness!

*Stern Face* Now, don't let it happen again!!!

Hee. Kidding.

xxxxxxx

Tuesday, May 22, 2007 9:50 PM

JANE0904


TamSibling, I think once in a while you have to stray into uncharted territory, if nothing else just to get these things out of your head!

In a way, reading DISORIENTED, it can be seen as non-slash, just two men who are able to show emotion to each other. Who knows, in 500 years time, maybe men will actually have evolved!

I understand what you mean about Simon/Kaylee, but it is, after all, up to us the writers to decide how Kaylee would react in a situation like that.

That said, I thought it was brilliantly written as always, and I say ... brava!


POST YOUR COMMENTS

You must log in to post comments.